Year Make Model Style Type
Tire prices are available online. Click here to start shopping.Need service? Looking for a deal? Check out our Coupons page!Get $40 off any set of four new tires! Click here for the coupon.GoodyearGoodyear
Tire prices are available online. Click here to start shopping.Need service? Looking for a deal? Check out our Coupons page!Get $40 off any set of four new tires! Click here for the coupon.
home01.jpgOur mission statement is simple. We strive to offer top-notch mechanical and preventive maintenance services and aggressively priced multi-brands of discount tires backed by unparalleled customer service. First Choice Car Care (Goodyear) was built on a foundation of going above and beyond for our clients. It starts with Mike and Laura and extends to every employee under our roof. We are proud of the team we’ve assembled; their dedication, their integrity and their sincere desire to make sure our clients and their vehicles receive the best possible care at a fair price. Really though, the only way to truly experience what we’re all about is to pay us a visit. You’re always welcome to stop by for a tour of the facility and of course, we’d be honored to have you as a client. We also provide service on classic cars, provide fleet customer discounts, diesels, as well as servicing RVs!

We feel we are Nassau county's best kept secret!  We do not mind the fact that our customers continually let their friends, co-workers, and family know about the genuine and honest service they receive from us each and every time they bring their vehicles to us.  We take great pride in having the most modern equipment in the area, from a Hunter DSP9700 Road Force Balancer, to a Hunter Hawk Eye Camera Alignment Equipment with a drive on flat rack.  We can even perform alignments on lowered vehicles to 4 door extended cab diesels.  Look on our website or come by to let us show you our multi branded discount tire deals, on your favorite brands such as, Michelin®, BFGoodrich®, Uniroyal®, Goodyear, Kelly, Dunlop, Firestone, Continental, Hankook, Kumho, Nexen, Pirelli, Yokohama, Nitto, and many more!

Our custom wheel packages come in many choices, such custom chrome wheels, polished wheels, painted wheels, and even custom wheels with a stripe.  We carry the latest 2011 custom wheel styles with brands are such as, Advanti Racing, Asanti, Blackrock, Bravado, Cragar, Cruiser Alloy, Drifz, ICW Racing, Konig, Lexani, Maas, Mickey Thompson, Pacer, and Ultra, as well as TSW.  We can even get your bent, cracked or damaged alloy or steel wheels repaired.

Tires up to 24 inches, alignments, oil changes, brakes, steering and suspension, and shocks and struts repair... That’s easy!  We can fix anything from a broken cup holder to a broken transmission!

We also specialize in suspension lift kits, lowering kits, as well as custom alignments requiring aftermarket suspension kits.

We also specialize in diagnostics with our GM Tech II scanner and Snap On Versus for domestic, import and even European vehicles.  We can update your vehicle's PCM with the manufacturer current program updated files!  We even have been known to fix hard top convertibles on a Pontiac G6 GT!

We also perform all manufacturer maintenance schedules and save you anywhere from 15% to 50% from what a dealer would charge; and it just depends on which mileage interval your vehicle is at.  We have an ASE master technician that can perform manufacturer recommended services on your Dodge, Chevrolet, Ford, Lincoln, Saab, BMW, Mercedes, Kia, Hyundai, Honda, Toyota, Nissan, Lexus, Infiniti, Mini Cooper, and even your MGB!  So whether you're from Callahan, Hilliard, Amelia City, Fernandina Beach, Kingsland, GA, or St. Marys, GA, First Choice has what you're looking for!

 Why We Hate Private Label Tires

Let’s get this out of the way right now ----We HATE “PRIVATE LABEL TIRES.” There is only one reason chain stores sell this kind of tire-- to keep you the consumer from accurately comparing tires from one store to the next.  This is always a chain store’s “go to” tire because it is the highest profit margin tire they sell. Typical reviews for this type of tire include; poor performance, noisy ride and premature tire wear. You will often hear “this tire is made by Cooper, Goodyear, Michelin®” or “insert another manufacturer’s name.” Just remember, if it is a Cooper tire it will be listed on the Cooper website!  Besides that, we’re not all that crazy about Cooper tires let alone some second tier tire they make for somebody else.

Some of the tires in this category are:  Multi Mile, American etc.  Even if you are not buying your tires from us PLEASE do yourself a favor and stick with a brand names like Goodyear, Michelin®, BFGoodrich®, Bridgestone,  Firestone, Hankook, Toyo, Continental, Nexen – you will get more tire for your $$$ and be happier in the long run.  

“Below average performance” and “average price for house brand tires” best describe these tires. They are “go to” tires for Walmart, Tire Kingdom, Costco, Sam’s and other chain companies. If you’re shopping a chain store – buy a name brand tire like  Michelin®, BFGoodrich®, Bridgestone, Firestone, Goodyear, Hankook, Toyo, or Yokohama and you will get a much better tire value, but sure tire is listed on manufacturer’s website.

All Brands
Promo x of x
  • All Brands
First Choice Goodyear Hours
Monday - Friday7:00 am6:00 pm
Saturday7:00 am5:00 pm

Mike's Events

Customer Testimonials

7-29-2010  John Travolta  (posted on YAHOO LOCAL

I would like to commend the staff at Goodyear in Yulee, FL. They offered fast reliable service and were extremely professional. I didnt have to sign any autographs or answer any silly questions. An all around wonderful experience.

6-21-11    Mike Dillon
 Mike, I would like to thank you and your staff for a job well done on my truck. I drove the truck 400 miles after I picked it up and it performs excellent, better than new. I took your rating survey and gave you the highest I could give. Very happy with all you did and I will return for service when needed for my car and truck. I would recommend you to anyone looking for service.

Thanks very much, Mike

see more testimonials

Tire Fitment Guide
or search tires by size...
Featured Tires
Monday - Friday7:00 am6:00 pm
Saturday7:00 am5:00 pm